The Republic
Commission & Inquiry Reports

Buhari II2018· Fate: Partially implemented· Chapter II · Law

Justice Galadima Police Reform Panel

Comprehensive reform of the NPF; mostly absorbed into the Police Act 2020.

The dossier

Formal title
Report of the Presidential Panel on Police Reform
Chair
Hon. Justice M. L. Garba / Hon. Justice Suleiman Galadima (rtd), JSC
Convened by
President Muhammadu Buhari
Inaugurated
August 2018
Submitted
November 2018
Status
Partially implemented through the Police Act 2020

Terms of reference

To review the operations of the Nigeria Police Force, including SARS, and recommend reform of its structure, funding, welfare and accountability.

What it found

  • SARS operated outside the ordinary command structure, with no unit-level accountability for arrests, detentions or deaths.
  • Police funding was inadequate and irregular; officers were routinely funded by the persons they policed.
  • The Police Act 1943 (as amended) was obsolete and inconsistent with Chapter IV of the Constitution.

What it recommended

  • A new Police Act replacing the 1943 statute; a Police Trust Fund; community policing.
  • Restriction of SARS to armed-robbery investigation, with a ban on roadblocks, stop-and-search of civilians and phone searches.
  • Independent, well-resourced Police Complaints Response Unit.

What became of it

The Nigeria Police Act 2020 and the Police Trust Fund Act 2019 enacted much of the statutory recommendation. The operational restrictions on SARS were announced at least four times between 2017 and 2019 and enforced none of them — the failure that produced #EndSARS in October 2020.

Listen to this entry0:00 / —:—

The Presidential Panel on the Reform of the Special Anti-Robbery Squad (SARS) of the Nigeria Police Force was constituted on 15 August 2018 by Acting President Yemi Osinbajo, following escalating public outcry—particularly on social media under the #EndSARS hashtag—over documented extrajudicial killings, torture, arbitrary detention, and extortion by SARS operatives across the country. The panel was constituted through the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) and chaired by its Executive Secretary, Tony Ojukwu, Esq. Justice Suleiman Galadima, a retired Justice of the Supreme Court, served as a senior legal member of the panel providing judicial gravitas to its proceedings. The panel had a three-month mandate to investigate SARS abuses, receive petitions from victims, and advise the federal government on structural reforms to the unit and to the Nigeria Police Force broadly.

The panel held hearings across geopolitical zones, received hundreds of petitions documenting extrajudicial killings, sexual violence by SARS operatives, extortion of motorists and young professionals, and prolonged detention without charge. It found systemic command-and-control failures: SARS operatives operated largely without oversight from divisional police officers; there was no effective internal accountability mechanism; officers indicted for abuse faced inadequate sanction. The panel recommended that 37 SARS officers be dismissed from service and 24 others be criminally prosecuted. It also recommended the creation of a dedicated Police Accountability Directorate, mandatory body cameras, an independent civilian oversight mechanism, state police as a constitutional arrangement, and the immediate de-escalation of SARS from plainclothes urban stop-and-search operations.

The panel submitted its report to President Buhari in June 2019. Buhari directed the Inspector-General of Police to act on the state police recommendation and approved the dismissal of 37 SARS officers and prosecution of 24 others. In practice, the Police Service Commission moved slowly on dismissals and only a fraction of recommended prosecutions were initiated. The structural reforms—civilian oversight, body cameras, de-escalation of SARS—were not implemented. By October 2020, SARS had returned to its former patterns, precipitating the far larger #EndSARS uprising that required another round of panels to address.

What it cost — political & economic reality

The political and economic reality

Nigeria in 2018: who was in charge, the cabinet of the day, the GDP, and the crises that defined the period.

President · Fourth Republic

Muhammadu Buhari

2015–2023· APC

National reality

Two recessions (2016, 2020). Multiple naira devaluations. ASUU strike of 2022 closed federal universities for ~9 months. End SARS protests (Oct 2020); Lekki Toll Gate incident. Out-of-school children >18 million by 2022.

Crises of the period

  • 2016 recession + FX crisis
  • End SARS + Lekki Toll Gate (Oct 2020)
  • COVID-19 lockdown (2020)
  • 9-month ASUU strike (2022)
  • Naira redesign chaos (Q1 2023)

GDP (World Bank)

$494 bn (2015) → $477 bn (2022)

Cabinet (selected portfolios)

  • Finance

    Kemi Adeosun (2015–18); Zainab Ahmed (2018–23)

  • Justice (AGF)

    Abubakar Malami (SAN)

  • Education

    Mallam Adamu Adamu (2015–23)

  • Petroleum

    Muhammadu Buhari (concurrent); Min. of State Ibe Kachikwu then Timipre Sylva

Sources · Federal Gazette 2015–23 · CBN · NBS

Methodology

Tier 1 · primary

Courts. Gazettes. National archives.

Tier 2 · corroborating

OCCRP. HRW. BudgIT. TheCable.

Tier 4 · tertiary, flagged

Wikipedia only where primary is pending. Always labelled.